Big publishing repeats big music’s mistakes

pile-of-booksAs big publishing houses reluctantly move from dead trees to digital, they are stubbornly repeating the same misguided practices that big music used to self destruct.

First, some publishers have apparently decided to price ebooks higher than hardcover books. Customer are protesting (and giving the books one-star reviews on Amazon), but the publishers don’t seem concerned. Meanwhile, publishers are still insisting on ineffective and annoying DRM which only serves to harm legitimate buyers, without doing anything to prevent unauthorized copies from proliferating. We’ve seen this story before… How is it that folks at these publishers haven’t been paying attention? Or do they really think “but, with us, it’s different”? (Techdirt)

Big music had a much bigger time window to adjust to marketplace changes. When it made the the errors of crippling content with  DRM, illogical pricing and criminalizing its customers self production was still complex and expensive. Free and cheap tools now make it possible for anyone to produce great recordings with a computer and $1000 worth of audio gear. While labor intensive, self production, promotion and distribution can be done with no capital investment.  The tools for self publishing books are already fairly mature and even more accessible. Print on demand and access to virtual shelf space in stores like Amazon are available to anyone with no capital investment.

With publishers poor treatment of fans and readers along with taking the lions share of inflated prices, I have to wonder why any author would continue to work with them. I think we’ll see big publishing continue to follow big music into a permanently declining business of monetizing a back catalog of copyrights. Very few new works will be entrusted to them in the very near future.

One Response to “Big publishing repeats big music’s mistakes”

  1. Dr Dog says:

    Sad but true. ePub is becoming the dominant format for a lot of the new ereaders coming out. Its versatile and reasonably easy to manipulate even doing so by hand. Tools make it almost a slam dunk.

    Audio has one leg up that books do not. Music is generally a matter of time and place with a hint of generation preference thrown in (I haven’t listened to Caruso since college and I don’t particularly like Lady GaGa.) Books by certain authors on the other hand, have a timeless relevance. I can be as comfortable reading Verne, Dante, Tom Wolfe or Cory Doctrow. Point is I could spend what is left of my life reading out of the ePub selections of the Gutenberg Project and not spend another dime on a ‘current’ author.

    That is their risk and probably don’t see it.